Pulitzer comes home: For TV channels, winning journalism’s Nobel is no news
Srinagar: An eerie silence has enveloped the national television channels after three Associated Press (AP) photojournalists from Jammu and Kashmir were declared winners of 2020 Pulitzer Prize for feature photography.
Mukhtar Khan, Dar Yasin of Kashmir and Channi Anand of Jammu have been awarded for capturing “striking images of life” during 2019 lockdown, when Centre abrogated the special status of Jammu and Kashmir and divided the state into two union territories.
Soon after the awards were announced, most of the national television channels surprisingly blacked out the news. Even the liberal and independent news channels did not run a scroll.
Only news portals and online editions of newspapers including The Wire, The Week, Hindustan Times, Outlook, News 18, and NDTV among others carried the story. Barring a few, all websites were sourcing news from the wire agencies. Few independent websites, however, were carrying the stories from their correspondents.
Indo-Asian News Service (IANS) carried a story about the ‘controversy’ created by the Pulitzer Prize board by questioning “India’s legitimacy over Kashmir, calling the valley a “contested territory whose independence” was revoked and “executed through a communications blackout”.
Even a Twitter spat broke out between IANS features and strategic affairs editor Aarti Tikoo Singh and Chief Photographer at Xinhua News Agency, New Delhi Bureau Javed Dar.
“No Pulitzer for journalists who captured pictures of children whose parents were massacred by Pakistan-sponsored terrorists. No Pulitzer because no journalists cared to take pictures of the kids blown up due to IEDs planted by Hizb, Lashkar & Jaish. No Pulitzer because no one lobbied,” tweeted Aarti.
Minutes later Dar hit out at Aarti for what he termed as “embedded journalism”. “When you and your ilk were busy doing embedded journalism—riding in SUVs with protection in posh Srinagar areas to paint ‘normalcy’, we Kashmiri photojournalists were navigating coils of concertina & barricades to depict ground reality. Pulitzer Prize is the result of our body of work; rants in your case,” he said.
Contrary to the skewed coverage by television channels, international media went the whole hog to highlight the achievements of the trio. From Al Jazeera to The New York Times, there was fairly good coverage of the feat achieved by Kashmiri journalists. “AP’s Kashmir photographers win Pulitzer for lockdown coverage,” reads the Al Jazeera headline
The New York Times also themed its headline on the Kashmir coverage post- abrogation of Article 370 last year. “AP wins feature photography Pulitzer for Kashmir coverage,” read the NYT headline.
Even the government seemed to have withdrawn into the shell by not reacting to the achievement of the sons of the soil. However, in the afternoon, former Congress president Rahul Gandhi broke the jinx and congratulated the trio.
“Congratulations to Indian photojournalists Dar Yasin, Mukhtar Khan and Channi Anand for winning a Pulitzer Prize for their powerful images of life in Jammu & Kashmir. You make us all proud,” Gandhi tweeted.
However, a television channel picked up his tweet calling it a “self-goal”. ”Rahul puts Pulitzer over patriots,” screamed the television channel.
Former chief minister Omar Abdullah also congratulated the trio for the feat. “It’s been a difficult year for journalists in Kashmir & that’s saying something considering the last 30 years haven’t exactly been easy. Congratulations to @daryasin, @muukhtark_khan & @channiap on this prestigious award. More power to your cameras,” he tweeted
Iltija Mufti, daughter of incarcerated former chief minister Mehbooba Mufti raised the treatment meted to journalists in Kashmir. “Congratulations @daryasin, @muukhtark_khan for your exemplary photography capturing the humanitarian crisis in Kashmir post illegal abrogation of Article 370. Bizarre that our journalists win accolades abroad but are punished under draconian laws on home turf,” she said.