ADVERTISEMENT

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Except for money, Kashmir’s children learn everything

Kashmir Govt School Students

Irshad Mushtaq

In most Kashmiri homes, children are taught to respect elders, study hard, pray on time, and be content with what God has given. One lesson is almost always missing. Nobody explains to a child where money comes from, how it grows, and how people lose it. We think this can wait until college or the first salary, but research says that by then it is too late.

In 2013, Britain’s government-backed money guidance body asked researchers at the University of Cambridge to study how children learn about money. They found that most children’s money habits are formed by the age of seven. By then, a child understands that money has to be earned, that it can be saved for later, and that some choices cannot be undone. A later British parliamentary inquiry reported that a person’s money behaviour as an adult can be predicted from childhood skills like self-control and maths, with signs visible as early as age five. The years that matter most are not eighteen to twenty-five. They are three to ten.

What the World Does

Many countries already teach money from an early age. The OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, a group of 38 mostly developed countries) runs a worldwide school test called PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment). Its 2022 report shows that in Austria, money lessons are part of the school curriculum from the age of three, while Costa Rica makes them compulsory from pre-school onwards.

Malaysia, an Asian and Muslim-majority country with strong family values, is perhaps the best example for us. In 2012, its education ministry and central bank set money-learning standards for all children aged 3 to 17, so that every student gets about three hours of money lessons each year. Saudi Arabia made money lessons compulsory in Class 10 from 2022. In the United States, 35 states required a personal finance course to finish high school in 2024, up from seven in 2000. None of these countries wants to raise share traders. They want adults who can read a loan paper and spot a cheat.

India’s Plan Is Only Optional

India has a body for this work, the NCFE (National Centre for Financial Education). It was set up by RBI (Reserve Bank of India, which oversees banks), SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India, which oversees shares and mutual funds), IRDAI (the insurance regulator) and PFRDA (the pension regulator). India’s national plan recommends that money lessons begin as early as possible in schools, but it is only a recommendation. Under NCFE’s Money Smart School Programme, schools are invited, not required, to teach money lessons from Class 6 to Class 10. Only 3,751 schools have registered across the whole country. The programme is optional, and it starts at about age eleven, four years after a child’s money habits have already formed.

NCFE’s 2019 national survey of about 75,000 adults found that only 27 percent of Indians are financially literate, meaning they meet a basic standard of money knowledge and behaviour. Among women, the figure was just 21 percent. J&K (Jammu and Kashmir) scored 29 percent. That is slightly above the national figure, but it still means more than seven in ten adults here fall short.

We Save, but We Do Not Invest

Kashmiris are careful savers. Under PMJDY (Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana, the government’s zero-balance bank account scheme), J&K has 25.4 lakh account holders with ₹2,009 crore in deposits. That is about ₹7,900 per account, well above the national average of about ₹5,500.

The problem is what happens to those savings next. The NSE (National Stock Exchange) shows that J&K has about 15.2 lakh trading accounts out of 27.65 crore nationwide, around half a percent of the total, while J&K has about one percent of India’s population. AMFI (Association of Mutual Funds in India) data shows that J&K holds only about ₹11,706 crore in mutual funds, out of a national total of more than ₹80 lakh crore. A mutual fund pools small amounts from many people and invests them under an expert manager. Our money still goes mostly into gold, land, committees and loans to relatives, and more and more of it goes to people who promise to double it.

The national picture is not much better. SEBI’s 2025 survey of more than 90,000 households found that 63 percent of households have heard of market products, but only 9.5 percent invest. Only 36 percent of investors understand the market reasonably well, and 62 percent follow tips from friends, relatives, or social media rather than registered professionals. Meanwhile, RBI reports that household debt reached 41.9 percent of GDP. GDP (Gross Domestic Product) is the total value of everything the country produces in a year. More than half of this debt is personal loans and credit cards used to buy things rather than build assets.

The Fraud Bill

This is where the lack of money knowledge becomes real loss. J&K Police’s cybercrime unit reported that online frauds worth ₹184.91 crore were reported in J&K in 2025, and only ₹32.64 crore was recovered. Out of every hundred rupees stolen, fewer than eighteen came back.

The Ministry of Home Affairs told Parliament that before 2025, J&K had filed 14,476 fraud complaints since the national portal began, with ₹175.66 crore lost. The losses in 2025 alone were larger than that entire earlier total. The same official figures show that a Kashmiri victim loses about ₹1.2 lakh per complaint, compared with about ₹95,000 in Delhi and ₹55,000 in Bihar. Fewer of us may be reporting fraud, but those who are cheated lose more.

Many victims never file an FIR (First Information Report, the first official police complaint). The NCRB (National Crime Records Bureau) recorded only 185 cybercrime cases in J&K in 2023, even though thousands of complaints were made online. Police have warned about fake investment offers, people pretending to be officials, and “digital arrest” calls that have cost senior citizens in Srinagar large sums. Every one of these tricks works only on someone who does not know how real banks and real officers behave. That includes asking for an OTP, the one-time password your bank sends by SMS, which should never be shared.

Why We Stay Silent

Part of the reason is culture. In many homes, talking about money in front of children is considered rude, and parents hide household budgets to protect their children’s innocence. We believe happiness comes from family and faith, not bank balances. That is wise, but contentment and money sense do not contradict each other. Islam itself values honest earning, avoiding waste, keeping clear records, and providing for one’s family.

Trust is another reason. We lend without paperwork and invest because “he is a known person”. Fraudsters know this and come dressed as friends, relatives or officers. Our schools add to the problem by judging children on marks, not life skills. A Kashmiri child can solve a hard maths sum but cannot explain why nobody can legally guarantee ten percent profit every month.

What Must Change

Parents should begin before age seven. A piggy bank, a small weekly allowance and simple choices between spending now and saving for later teach more than any lecture. Schools should join NCFE’s free programme, and private schools that charge heavily from LKG (Lower Kindergarten) onwards can easily give one period a week to money lessons. The School Education Department can follow Malaysia and make a short money module compulsory in every class, taught in Kashmiri, Urdu and English. Banks and police cyber cells should take fraud awareness into classrooms, before today’s teenagers start using UPI (Unified Payments Interface, the system behind Google Pay and PhonePe) and credit cards. Every family should also remember the cyber fraud helpline, 1930, because police say quick reporting is the best way to get stolen money back.

Kashmir has produced generations of doctors, engineers and scholars. Our children do not lack intelligence or values. What they lack is an early, honest conversation about money. Other countries start that conversation at three. We put it off until a fraud call or a lost life’s savings forces it on us. Teaching a child to save, to wait and to question is not greed. It is protection, and it must begin before the child turns seven.

(The author is a Jammu and Kashmir-based financial educator, columnist and founder of M I Securities, Srinagar. This article is for general awareness and is not investment advice)