Srinagar. Jan 27: Close on the heels of a number of critical international statements and parliamentary resolutions, the government is bracing for six scathing resolutions on both Jammu and Kashmir and the Citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA), 2019, that have been filed by an overwhelming majority of members in the European Parliament.
These will be taken up for discussion and
voting this week.
The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA)
declined an official comment on the resolutions, which could have a deep impact
on ties between India and the European Union.
“We are informed that some members of the
EU Parliament intend to move a draft resolution on the CAA. The CAA is a matter
that is entirely internal to India. Moreover, this legislation has been adopted
by due process and through democratic means after a public debate in both
Houses of Parliament,” sources in the government said.
They added that the government hoped that
the sponsors of the draft would engage with New Delhi for an “accurate
assessment of the facts before they proceed”.
The draft resolutions (numbering from
B9-0077/2020 to B9-0082/2020) are due to be taken up during the plenary session
of the European Parliament in Brussels on January 29 for discussion (around 6
p.m. local time) and January 30 for a vote.
The European Commission Vice-President/High
Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy (HR/VP)
Josep Borell will first deliver a statement on “India’s Citizenship (Amendment)
Act 2019”, the published plenary agenda says. The EU parliament had discussed
developments in Jammu and Kashmir in September 2019, but had not ended in a
vote. In October 2019 the government had even facilitated a visit by 22 EU MEPs
to Delhi and Srinagar, but the effort doesn’t appear to have had the desired
effect on the European Parliament.
The current resolutions, each of which is
worded slightly differently and focuses mainly on the CAA, will be introduced
by six different political groups representing a total of 626 of the total 751
members of the European Parliament (MEPs). (Courtesy: The Hindu)
India snubs move, says ‘entirely internal’
New Delhi, Jan 27: Amidst diplomatic
backlash from the European Union (EU) Parliament on the Citizenship Amendment
Act (CAA) and the restrictions in Jammu and Kashmir, New Delhi has strongly
reiterated that these matters are entirely internal to India.
This came as 626 of the 751 members of the
EU Parliament moved six resolutions on CAA and Kashmir in a bid to pressure
A total of six resolutions have been tabled
by groups within the European Union (EU), including the Group of the
Progressive Alliance of Socialists and Democrats in the European Parliament
(S&D), Group of the European People’s Party (Christian Democrats) (PPE),
Group of the Greens/European Free Alliance (Verts/ALE), European Conservatives
and Reformists Group (ECR), Renew Europe Group (Renew) and European United
Left/Nordic Green Left (GUE/NGL) Group.
The EU Parliament is set to debate on the
resolutions tabled by a large chunk of its members, saying the enactment of the
new law “marked a dangerous shift in India’s citizenship regime”.
“The CAA marks a dangerous shift in the way
citizenship will be determined in India and is set to create the largest
statelessness crisis in the world and cause immense human suffering,” the
“Instead of addressing the concerns,
offering corrective action, calling for security forces to act with restraint
and ensuring accountability, many government leaders have been engaging in
efforts to discredit, rebuke and threaten the protesters,” the resolution
The resolutions have urged the Indian
authorities to “engage constructively” with those protesting against the law
and consider their demands to repeal the “discriminatory CAA”.
In response to the draft resolution,
sources in the Ministry of External Affairs said the government took note of
the EU move immediately and will withstand the EU pressure by reminding its
members that the CAA is “an internal matter” of India.
“CAA is a matter that is entirely internal
to India. This legislation has been adopted by due process and through
democratic means after a public debate in Parliament.”
India hopes that the “sponsors and
supporters” of the resolutions will engage with the government to get a full
and accurate assessment of facts before they proceed further, the sources said.
They further said that “as fellow
democracies, the EU Parliament should not take actions that call into question
the rights and authority of democratically elected legislatures in other
regions of the world”.
“Every society that fashions a pathway to
naturalisation contemplates both a context and criteria. This is not
discrimination. In fact, European societies have followed the same approach,” a
government source quoted by PTI said, explaining why India is opposed to the
resolutions at the EU parliament.
However, an official statement by the MEA
on the resolutions is yet to be made.
The resolutions, set to be debated in the
European Parliament in Brussels next Wednesday and voted the day after, come
less than two months before Prime Minister Narendra Modi is likely to travel to
Brussels for the India-EU summit on March 13.
The CAA came into force in India last
December amid massive protests in India.
The new law, passed by Parliament last
month, offers citizenship to non-Muslim persecuted religious minorities from
Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan. India has been witnessing massive
protests against the new law with opposition parties, civil rights groups and
activists saying granting citizenship based on religion is against the
foundational principle of the Constitution.
The Government has been emphasising that
the new law does not deny any citizenship rights, but has been brought to
protect the oppressed minorities of neighbouring countries and give them
Interestingly, the resolutions come in the
backdrop of EU diplomats not visiting Jammu and Kashmir along with 15 other
foreign envoys earlier this month.
Earlier it was reported that certain
European envoys were not keen on a ‘guided tour’ of J-K and rather wanted to
meet the people they wanted to interact with.
However, the Indian government junked the
reports as ”unfounded and mischievous” and said that the envoys will undertake
the trip at a later date.
Earlier in October last, a delegation of Members
of European Parliament (MEPs) had reached Jammu and Kashmir to assess the
situation on the ground even as sporadic incidents of violence were reported
from the Valley following the abrogation of Article 370. (Agencies)